Wednesday, May 30, 2012

School Playgrounds Become Graveyards MubeensBlog #MubeensLaw


 MubeensBlog #MubeensLaw
This Article has been written in response to a successful Twitter Trend run by Pakistanis around the globe to create an awareness and state of emergency to wake up our nation to our deteriorating values and Educational System.

The past two months have been buzzing with more or less the same Political nonsense in Pakistan. As usual the point of focus has been our distinguished Leadership. The never ending debate on inflation, power-cuts and cowardly foreign policy has been the driving force for many social networking sites. Television has practically become a Political forum for politicians to come together and deface each other.

Amidst this hue and cry, I began to come across snippets of a strange kind of viral disease infiltrating our society silently but surely. “A topper Kamran, from Grade 7 committed suicide by burning himself over not being able to wear a new uniform which his parents could not afford coming from a poor family. His father earned his living through odd jobs. His treatment was an estimated 2 million rupees of which the parents were able to collect just 50,000. Before his treatment began, he lost his life owing to some incredible desire to wear a new uniform.”

No sooner than that happened news of another young 7th grader studying and residing in an elite school’s hostel in Abbottabad started to make waves. “The name was Mobeen and he often spend weekends at home with his family. One dreadful weekend, he came home to wrap up his entire life into a loop of shame and humiliation that he faced at the hands of the teachers who taught him and the misbehaviour of management at the hostel. 

Mobeen left a note in his school jacket that revealed his frustration and shocking revelations on being punished and fined Rs. 5 for using Urdu in school. More evidence of his trying days at the school was printed in his personal diary that he mentioned in his last note.”

And to add to this grievance, a 6th grader in Karachi made a successful suicidal attempt at failing an assessment in school in North Nazimabad.

Along with these shocking tales of dead ends, off and on we hear the news of physical beatings and sexual abuse in lower level schools by teachers and headmasters alike. News of children being rushed to hospitals because they were unable to answer the teacher’s question should become a matter of grave concern for all of us.

Our Education System has failed to deliver the sanity of learning to our children and playgrounds are slowly becoming harsh realities of graveyards.

Education aims primarily to provide equal opportunity to each child and equips them with the tools to reason well. The above examples of students as old as 12, claiming their lives indicates a huge shift of priorities and clearly reflects the presence of a rigid force that adamantly denies a system failure.

There would be much debate upon government schools versus private institutions. The middle class struggles to get their children admitted to Private schools despite the high fee structure. Once they are able to get in, the entire pressure to perform is shifted to the child who neither applied for the honour nor anticipated the cut-throat competition. Here the child’s ability becomes irrelevant to the result expected. The father wants the fee to be justified through an “A” performance and the school sends reminders consistently to meet their high standards.

Government schools on the other hand hold no motivation what so ever for either student or teacher. The concept of interactive learning is almost nil and the future for these children is acceptably decided which kills their dreams to think big. Here the teachers set no expectations of their students and the parents harshly unveil their disappointment by reminding them of the effort being made to educate them despite being poor.

Crushed between these two forces, the school and the parent, the child begins to struggle more with his weaknesses than his strengths. The focus is always the failure, the inadequacy or the childish attitude! This vicious cycle leads the child to believe and take responsibility for these failures, inadequacies and childish attributes. Any abuse at this difficult time, physical or emotional, can damage the reasoning ability of the child. At such a tender age the amount of stress to produce expected results ignites a spark of frustration. There is dislike for oneself. This dislike and constant negativity leads to drastic consequences which are sometimes fatal.

A perfectly harmonious system begins with a fair distribution of resources to schools from the government. Standard Training programmes for teachers to promote desired teaching methodologies and incentives to progress and grow in the profession. Create standard criterion for hiring teachers and indulge in regular school inspections to evaluate the learning happening. Children should be involved in etching their learning graph. Provisions for support classes and teachers should be made available to all schools to release the stress of being alone in the process. The focus should be to enhance the strengths of each child and provide equal opportunity to move ahead.

Parental involvement in academic and social changes should be welcomed and voluntary work should be encouraged. This will awaken the parents to the reality of most situations related to their child’s fundamental growth. It will help them relate to their children’s problems. Communication will definitely identify the working of the mind and maybe the hopelessness of meeting with a dead end could be avoided. Faith in our children encourages them to admissions and confessions.

But most importantly, the impact of over-competition needs to be aborted at once. Every child needs to experience a moment of glory which remains the responsibility of the teacher. Identifying the strongest needs and desires of the pupil and creating a stage for its attainment is indeed one of the most noble gesture and efforts made by a teacher.

Punishment of any physical nature should be labelled a criminal act by law. The parliament of our country should work in collaboration with school systems to devise a law that protects and safeguards the rights of these innocent children who deserve a happy school life. Any teacher who raises the hand to exhibit his power should be expelled with a heavy fine and be barred from this noble profession.

It’s difficult to imagine those young chaotic minds that carried such huge scars. The little hearts that dreaded another day at school. The fear that engulfed them on announcing their failure and the injustice that devoured their sense of pride.

Children are the future. We must take charge of this drowning situation which is growing at an alarming rate. Our government needs to take notice of this epidemic and invest its energies into formulating a much needed Education System that runs a fair and Balanced Academic Programme for all and is monitored by firm Laws and Strict Accountability!





Tuesday, May 15, 2012

Reality With Equality


After a break of 3 years I shall finally be reverting to my passion of teaching and learning. I was fortunate to land a job in an absolutely new School environment. The management hired me as an English Language teacher for Grades 4 and 5 and as the Language Co-ordinator.

I spent a week with them to get myself Oriented with the system and routines. I was pleasantly surprised at being greeted by the students with my name though I had interacted with them through a demo lesson almost a month and a half back. Their smiles welcomed me with warmth and I felt a strong sense of belonging already.

Having taught English for almost 10 years, I felt I only needed to get myself acquainted with The American Curriculum which is again a fresh concept to me. Well, quite honestly what is a book to a teacher? The challenge is always to create a story around the content and concept to facilitate the learning process. But I believe there will be surprises thrown my way this coming academic year!

I attended an English Workshop at the school through the week and as always it was a great adrenaline rush! It challenged all my prior concepts on teaching language, methodology, possibilities and doubts. I was seated with fellow language teachers and luckily the programme being discussed was to be implemented the coming year and so the term, “Balanced Literacy Programme” was new to all.

The philosophy behind the programme should touch the heart of every True Educationist. Every classroom, especially one composed of Non-native speakers, consists of different levels of objectives. One of the teacher declared she had six different levels in her class with regards to Reading and Writing. To meet the needs of all these levels was a task for her and planning six different lessons an impossibility and an accepted failure at application too.

The Balanced Literacy Programme aims at creating different learning centres within the classroom and creating homogeneous student groups. All students within a group reflect the same levels of understanding and work towards achieving the same language targets together. The year begins with homogeneity and the desired plan is to build them into heterogeneous groups as the levels improve.

The idea comes across beautifully but I do wonder if the concept would be smooth and workable. It is possible to create four distinct Language Skill Centres within the classroom but how would these centres function independently as the teacher would skip from one group to another. Would the writers be comfortable with their thoughts while the readers would recite their lines aloud? Could the grammar activities be carried out without teacher intervention? More importantly, could the students benefit more from their peers than the teacher?

I raised a few of my concerns.

“Anything that’s new, takes a little time to seep in. It’s not just adopting something new but also letting go of something old and familiar.” 

The Supervisor encouraged all the questions understanding the natural reaction of most teachers towards the need for such a change.

“There’s been a huge debate after a recent evaluation of many Private Schools whereby it was reported that almost every child was oblivious of his/her growth and role in the educative process. These were brilliant students and it was eye opening to observe their absence of reasoning and logic.”

“The second glaring discrepancy to meet the eye was the presence of many different student levels within the classroom resulting in lack of 100% engagement through a singular lesson. The Knowledge and Human Department Authority issued their expected criteria to schools to fill in these two very important learning pits.”

“It takes about a month for this programme to settle in. The centres remain for a week and student groups rotate every day to a new centre. The assignments are all computer generated and it’s a more Scientifically graded programme.”

“The Programme allows a certain healthy noise level to persist within the class walls. Students share ideas and problems to find solutions and are far more aware of their growth and learning. The objectives are written by them and ticked off upon attainment.”

Looking at the programme from the very definition, there is a balance that can be envisioned rightfully. To me, anything that promises Reality with Equality is welcomed with much excitement.

So what if I hold a few reservations. The opportunity to try out something new that might actually work around to bring justice within a system is definitely worth an honest attempt!